UNWELL WOMAN

dir. Daniella DeVinter

Still from "Unwell Woman" (dir. Daniella DeVinter). Features a woman from the shoulders up, in a tank top with shoulder length hair and eye makeup. She gazes at something intensely just above the camera lens. The image is cast in a blue glow.

We can blame the Ancient Greeks for the etymology of that incendiary word, hysteria, though the Egyptians were the progenitors of the concept; the Greek term for uterus, hystera, is generally agreed to be the linguistic root. This is because history has regarded hysteria as a solely female condition – a madness entirely unique to women with wombs. 

The madness, according to the Greeks, lay in not wanting to use the womb. 

Daniella DeVinter’s Unwell Woman is haunted by hysteria, as entangled and bound by it as the film’s nameless protagonist (Lydia Makrides) is ensnared by her mother’s fate. Placed in the enticingly Gothic surroundings of a Cambridge library in 1979, we are introduced to our smartly-dressed protagonist as a haunting cover of Kate Bush’s “Wuthering Heights” plays in the background (“You say I killed you – haunt me then […] Drive me mad!”). She is bold, disruptive, and different from all the other students studying. Immediately likeable, if you can look past her questionable choice in pencil case, decorated with an eerie, turgid-nosed clown. To round off her study session, she has also elected to bring the most ostensibly haunted photograph of her mother she could find. 

And it was taken in that very same library…! 

Our protagonist has been so preoccupied with packing various pieces of spooky memorabilia that she has neglected to bring a pencil. She asks a faceless woman nearby quite politely for one; the woman hands her a pen. 

DeVinter’s student is reading Studies on Hysteria, by Josef Brueur and Sigmund Freud, which is a double act guaranteed to drive anyone to madness even if they weren’t heading in that direction anyway. The authors babble clinically in our ears as the protagonist works her way through the text and the library empties and day slides to night. She is alone in the dark – except Brueur and Freud hang over her shoulders like malignant shadows, trailing cigar smoke, dressed to the nines and critically narrating their predatory case studies of hysterical young women. They poke and prod at her, hissing diagnoses, and that is when the painting starts talking. 

The painting was not visible before, in case you were wondering. 

The painting’s subject, a morbid woman dressed entirely in black, chastises the protagonist for not using a pencil to take her notes, and as punishment, elects to tell her a tale of her past using the medium of charmingly animated stop-motion paper puppets. Perhaps this happens to all students foolish enough to deface Cambridge library property. Unlike our badly-behaved vandalistic protagonist, the painting tells a story of a girl who was purely, perfectly good.

Good in the eyes of a misogynistic, repressive society, anyway, aside from a secret passion for painting that she nurtured by moonlight. But even this incredibly mild vice could not continue once she married the monster in the bedroom, represented here by a suitably Freudian jack-in-the-box clown springing to attention in the marital bed. An abrupt switch to live action once more, as our dutiful wife attempts to escape the consequences of her wretched marriage. She slides open the horrible clown pencil case, an apparent family heirloom, revealing an innocuous-looking pencil. 

Then she steps out of her underwear, braces herself over the toilet, and stabs upwards. 

This is female mania as the Greeks had it first; denial of motherhood, of hostile occupation of the womb by an invading force. The painting’s narration tells us that the unfortunate artist failed in her desperate measures. Her botched abortion resulted in the young scholar who listens in horror as Freud and Brueur gloat at her side. You’re scaring me, she protests, but the painting will not be appeased. What’s scary is a monster that crawls in your cunt and fucks with your head! Madness and motherhood, inextricably intertwined. 

Mum? asks our protagonist, and the painting melts away to reveal a naked, snarling skull. 

Unwell Woman ends badly for our doomed protagonist. She was set up to fail – handed a pen when she asked for a pencil, provoking the painting’s wrath. Handed the weight of her mother’s suicide hanging above her. And some historical scholars claimed hysteria was hereditary, suggesting that it could be passed down from woman to girl-child like hair colour or skin tone. You say I killed you – drive me mad! 

Daniella DeVinter creates a compelling, tidy tale that is a delight to watch. The editing crosses from playful to menacing without ever venturing too far into camp, and the cinematography is polished and beautiful. Special kudos to James Tearing for an eerie score, and Penelope Whitehouse for her haunting animation. Unwell Woman is a confident indie film, and it deserves to be.

Lia Mulcahy adores all things horrific and fantastical. She has work published in Bloodletter, Seize the Press, Flux, Glyph, and Flash Fiction Magazine. She has previously won in a creative writing competition by the Irish Times, and is currently a student editor of Caveat Lector.

Back to Bloodline