ECHO
dir. Victoria Long

Echo by Victoria Long is a short film about the relationship between desire and transformation. The desire to resist transformation. The transformation that results in giving in to desire.
The protagonist, Ava, happily greets her partner, Liam, when he returns from an unsuccessful attempt at identifying the wreckage of an ocean crash site. Early on, we know something is odd about their relationship. Ava receives a call from an unknown user, and tells them, “What if I try to talk to him? What if I try to explain to him what’s been happening and then maybe–” only to be cut off. While eating breakfast together, Liam contorts his face as if in some indescribable pain. Ava notices but says nothing.
Later, they walk together in the woods holding hands, and Liam confesses he wants to have a child with Ava. They have sex. That evening, Liam transforms—while his bodily form remains intact, his mind is evidently controlled by some other source. He does not remember who Ava is and threatens to shoot her. He is taken out by a task force that is working with Ava to capture him. We are told he died two years prior, and he has been back ten times before.
In Cruel Optimism, affect theorist Lauren Berlant explains that desirable objects embody a cluster of promises. In this film, Liam (the desirable object) represents love, affection, and stability for Ava. When Liam returns home, he is no longer himself–we are told that he is a dangerous creature (referred to as “it”) targeted by the military. At the end of the film, a military agent says, “You know Liam was buried two years ago, after his helicopter went down. Whoever that is, it’s not Liam.” This provides neither solace nor comfort for a conflicted Ava.
Sometimes we desire objects that are bad for us; Berlant calls this ‘cruel optimism’: “the condition of maintaining an attachment to a significantly problematic object.”1 We can take Liam’s transformation to be literal–perhaps he is an evil creature that poses a threat to humanity. Despite rationally understanding Liam’s transformation, Ava is still unable to perceive him as a monster. She is internally struggling between the reality of Liam and the promise of Liam, and in the end, her desire for his past self outweighs her knowledge of his present self. Ava’s inability to resist desire may result in a transformed risk. It is unclear what this monster-Liam may pass on to his offspring. In this case, the possibility of their child represents a future threat, unknown to the military.
When the military agent reminds Ava of Liam’s death, she challenges this assumption: “That’s what you say, but what do you know?” Perhaps Liam did not literally die while on the mission. Liam exists as a metaphor for those transformed by PTSD. He is “lost” while on a mission and comes back with an altered identity. He continues to be haunted and terrorized by the military even in his own home. Through this lens, the possibility of their child is a desire for a family unit, an attempt to resist Liam’s transformation and return to structure and normalcy.
In the final shot of the film, Ava stands with her back to the camera, watching Liam’s body burn. Although his body is gone, the agent hints that he will come again. How will Ava face her cruel optimism next time? Echo provides no answer, and yet, the power of the film is rooted in this ambiguity. Whether or not Liam’s character represents a monster, a psychological response, or some combination of both, his echoes are resounding.
1 Lauren, Berlant, Cruel Optimism (Durham: Duke University Press, 2011), 23.
Lexi Franciszkowicz is a teacher in Chicago. Her writing has most recently been published in Bloodletter, Weird Lit Magazine, and The Pub.